Uncategorized

Safety Law News for July 30, 2021

by  • 

— In Ohio, the United States Court of Appeals ruled that city officials did not violate federal law when their negligence allowed a police officer impersonator to assault and falsely imprison students.  The court held that claims based on the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment and Title VI of the Civil Rights Act were not designed to address the negligence.  The court concluded that the SRO program, fraught with poor implementation, should be the subject of state-based claims. M.J. by & through S.J. v. Akron City School District Board of Education

— In Illinois, the school resource officer program has been temporarily suspended due to staffing shortages at the police department.  The press release by school officials and the police department says the officers previously deployed to the schools will be reassigned.  Educators say, “a resource officer is necessary in a school. They’re very helpful… resource officers were a good source of someone trusted [students] could go to and talk to if there was a problem.”

— In Virginia, the superintendent of the Alexandria City Public Schools has notified the school board that time is running out on providing a “contingency plan with regards to safety and security mitigations for our students and staff.”  The Alexandria City Council voted to redirect nearly $800,000 in SRO funding toward student mental health resources.  The superintendent proposes that the school district hire private security officers and retain through a new agreement police officers to work the perimeter of schools during the school day.

— In Arkansas, Conway School District officials are revising their school resource officer program.  Instead of using a dedicated school resource officer at each campus, the new model will use multiple officers to cover all the schools. The officers will visit the schools as part of their regular, daily patrols.

Uncategorized

Safety Law News for July 28, 2021

by  • 

— In Virginia, United States Court of Appeals, reversed a judgment against a student who was sexually assaulted by another student and remanded the case for a new trial.  The Title IX case alleged that the school acted with deliberate indifference to the situation.  The jury found that the school had no notice.  On appeal, the court ruled that the findings of the jury ignored the evidence, e.g., written statements by the victim and the victim’s mother, as well reports from other students. Doe v. Fairfax County School Board

— In Florida, students and parents in Osceola County are adjusting to the removal of police officers from their schools.  Private security company employees are being trained to perform the role that state law requires to make them “school guardians.”  The officers undergo 104 hours of firearms training and 16 hours of human diversity instruction.  Some parents believe “[i]t’s better to have an officer,” because the guardian training is deficient in “how to relate to students, to detect signs of mental and behavioral stress, and to de-escalate student conflicts.”

— The results of a study conducted by scholars from Boston University, the University of Colorado Boulder and Harvard University found a causal link exists between students who experience strict school discipline and being arrested or incarcerated as an adult.  Their data identifies school administrators, who control the suspension and expulsion of students, as the “major driver” in the frequency and severity of school discipline.

— In Illinois, officials in the City of Elgin are implementing a program designed to keep local youth from getting involved with gangs and violence.  In a collaboration of schools, police, community organizations, faith groups and volunteer mentors, the program will train young people in the habits of making positive choices.

Uncategorized

Safety Law News for July 23, 2021

by  • 

— In New York, the Supreme Court, Appellate Division reversed a lower court and dismissed a lawsuit brought by parents whose daughter was sexually assaulted by another student while they were alone in a classroom.  The court agreed that schools “will be held liable for foreseeable injuries proximately related to the absence of adequate supervision,” but ruled that there was no evidence of any prior misconduct similar to the assault that would put educators on notice.  The assailant’s disciplinary history consisted of attendance issues, academic problems, insubordination, verbal outbursts, drug and alcohol possession and use, and sale of drugs.  Knaszak v. Hamburg Central School District

— In California, the school board for the Folsom Cordova Unified School District unanimously renewed the school resource officer program for their 33 schools.  A prior vote of the board to eliminate the contract with the police, was reversed after revisions were made to the agreement to address transparency and accountability issues.

— In North Carolina, the Wake County Public Schools will sue Juul Labs, alleging harmful health effects of the company’s vaping products on students.  The decision comes just after the announcement of the $40 million settlement between the Juul Labs and the State of North Carolina in July 2021.

— Nationally, a survey from Safe and Sound Schools reports a gap between parents and administrators in perceptions of school safety. The results of the survey, which was conducted among district administrators, public safety staff, students, teachers, and parents, suggest that administrators are significantly more confident than parents in schools’ safety policies and procedures. 

Uncategorized

Safety Law News for July 19, 2021

by  • 

— In Pennsylvania, the Superior Court of Pennsylvania affirmed the adjudication of delinquency of a student for terroristic threats for a state law that forbids communicating, “either directly or indirectly, a threat to…(1) commit any crime of violence with intent to terrorize another….[or] otherwise cause serious public inconvenience, or cause terror or serious public inconvenience with reckless disregard of the risk of causing such terror or inconvenience.” 18 Pa.C.S. §§ 2706(a)(1) – (a)(3).  The student post in the Internet said, “I don’t really have any friends and if I would to perhaps shoot the fucking school up right now I would be looked at as crazy, right?”  The court ruled that, although the student claimed he was just expressing frustration, he “acted with at least reckless disregard in causing terror or serious public inconvenience to his fellow classmates and/or the administrative and security staff of the school.” Int. of K.M.M.B.

— In Colorado, the Poudre School District Board of Education voted to continue the funding for its school resource officer program.  The board is revising the school safety policies to more clearly define the role of the officers.

— In Rhode Island, the legislature has enacted House Bill 5555, the Harold M. Metts School Safety Act of 2021, which prohibits people from bringing guns onto school property. The only exceptions are for school security personnel, peace officers and retired law enforcement members. Hawaii, Kansas, New Hampshire, Oregon, Utah and Wyoming still allow concealed-carry exceptions in schools.

— In Maryland, The Howard County Board of Education has approved the School Resource Officer contract for the upcoming school year.  The agreement requires training for SROs in Restorative Justice Practices, Culturally Responsive Practices, Racial Equity, Disability Awareness, De-escalation Practices, and other training specifically aimed at addressing racial, ethnic, and class disparities in how students are treated.

Uncategorized

Safety Law News for July 9, 2021

by  • 

— In Maryland, the Court of Special Appeals of Maryland ruled that school officials were immune from claims of negligent school discipline in a case involving repeated attacks upon a student by fellow-students.  The victim argued that steps taken by the school were not solving the problem.  The court ruled that, “Maryland does not recognize a tort action seeking damages based on negligent education,” particularly after implementing the restorative model of student discipline that uses “discipline as more of a learning tool, and less of a punishment.”  The court also ruled that the Paul D. Coverdell Teacher Protection Act, was a federal law source of teacher immunity in the case.  Brandon Gambrill v. Board of Education of Dorchester County

— In Rhode Island, the Supreme Court of Rhode Island ruled that school officials were liable for harm to a student by a fellow-student who, “despite numerous instances of misbehavior, including conduct that violated the high school’s sexual harassment and anti-bullying policies…received no progressive punishment.”  The court held that the restorative justice policies would not protect the school when, “there is evidence that the school district exercised no degree of care in the face of a known, foreseeable danger.”  Dextraze v. Bernard.

— In Illinois, school officials in Schaumburg and Hoffman Estates will renew the three-year agreements with their police departments to provide school resource officers to the schools.  The officers teach (internet safety, drug and gang resistance, and stranger danger), assist with truancy and residency issues, and interact with students as positive role models.

— In Massachusetts, the Yarmouth Police Department is working with the schools to host a Summer Cop Camp for all youths aged 10 to 13. The 5-week camp is free of charge and will feature the different jobs and functions of police work as well as engage with children in fun events utilizing the school grounds.

Uncategorized

Safety Law News for July 2, 2021

by  • 

— In Texas, the United States Court of Appeals ruled that a school resource officer was not liable for tasing a special education student who was trying to leave the school after engaging in disruptive behavior.  The Court held that Texas law does provide remedies for students who experience corporal punishment in schools.  In addition, federal law substantive due process claims based on school discipline are not allowed.   Finally, the court ruled that the law on whether a student has a Fourth Amendment right to be free of excessive disciplinary force was inconsistent with the facts of the case such that the SRO was entitled to qualified immunity.  J. W. v. Paley

— In North Carolina, E-cigarette company Juul agreed to pay North Carolina $40 million to settle allegations that the company aggressively marketed its vaping products to young people.  North Carolina is the first state to reach a settlement with Juul.  Other jurisdictions have also sued the e-cigarette company.

— In Virginia, officials in Alexandria are acknowledging that their schools face major security issues after the elimination of the school resource officer program.  The decision to shift funding to increase mental health resources leaves the schools without a police presence.  One of the schools is the largest high school in Virginia.

— In Rhode Island, both the Senate and the House passed legislation which would prohibit anyone, with certain exceptions, from bringing a firearm onto school property.  Senate Bill 2021-S 0073 and House Bill 2021-H 5555A prohibit the possession of firearms on school grounds except for peace officers, retired law enforcement officers, persons under contract to provide school security services, and unloaded firearms in locked containers or a locked rack in a motor vehicle.